How to sell a contradiction. The logic and methaphysics of inconsistency (Q2786386)
From MaRDI portal
| This is the item page for this Wikibase entity, intended for internal use and editing purposes. Please use this page instead for the normal view: How to sell a contradiction. The logic and methaphysics of inconsistency |
scientific article; zbMATH DE number 5789976
| Language | Label | Description | Also known as |
|---|---|---|---|
| English | How to sell a contradiction. The logic and methaphysics of inconsistency |
scientific article; zbMATH DE number 5789976 |
Statements
22 September 2010
0 references
abstraction
0 references
consistency
0 references
contradiction
0 references
deductive syllogism
0 references
liar
0 references
paraconsistency
0 references
paradoxes
0 references
triviality
0 references
How to sell a contradiction. The logic and methaphysics of inconsistency (English)
0 references
This book presents, with admirable coherence and full referencing, the development of paraconsistent logic. There are good arguments that the Liar sentence is true, and that it is false. Traditional approaches tried to discredit one or the other; paraconsistent logicians accept that it is both. Immediately we are faced with the ``explosive'' nature of contradictions: that from a contradiction, any statement whatever can be inferred (\textit{ex falso quodlibet}), and hence a system which permits contradictions must reject such inferences or be doomed to triviality. Again, an unrestricted principle of set abstraction would be very attractive did it not lead to inconsistency. Berto summarises paraconsistent systems due to Jaskowski, Rescher \& Brandom, da Costa and colleagues, the relevance logic community, and Graham Priest; and gives some discussion of their applications, particularly to inconsistent arithmetics.NEWLINENEWLINEOne annoying production problem: in many cases (e.g., p. 77) what were intended to be Greek words have been printed as a mish-mash of Latin letters. It is to be hoped that this will be corrected in the second edition of this important book.
0 references