Thurstonian-type representations for ``same-different'' discriminations: deterministic decisions and independent images.
type: Item
instance of: scholarly article
title: Thurstonian-type representations for ``same-different'' discriminations: deterministic decisions and independent images.
zbMATH Open document ID: 1048.91103
DOI: 10.1016/S0022-2496(02)00027-5
author: Ehtibar N. Dzhafarov
published in: Journal of Mathematical Psychology
publication date: 2003-07-29T00:00:00Z
review text: The original Thurstonian representation idea applies to greater-less comparison of given pairs of stimuli (e.g.\ noise), and the presumption is that individuals map stimuli into a perceptual space (`loudness'), so that to each stimulus one can assign a probability distribution on the perceptual space representing the possible values the stimulus can be mapped to, and relative probabilities; to test this presumption the theory starts with data on stimuli comparisons, and seeks a pair of probability distributions on the perceptual space which generate the given data; and the theorems seek conditions on the data which guarantee the existence of a representation in terms of probability pairs. The author's present work is concerned with extending this Thurstonian ideas to same-different comparisons (where naturally the perception space is no longer unidimensional but can be much more general), and presents a negative `regularity' result. In the present setting the data are represented by `psychometric' functions describing the probability with which a pair of stimuli (in The Euclidean space) are distinguished; and the result reported is roughly that for psychometric functions satisfying some `reasonable' properties there exists no `smooth' probabilistic representation in any perceptive space. The reason is that such smooth representations generate `smooth' psychometric functions, while `reasonable' functions of this kind naturally lack the given smoothness. In fact it is is not difficult to imagine that the latter functions' graphs may look like pointed cones, with minima for pairs of stimuli most likely perceived as `same'. The author concludes with a word of skepticism about Thurstonian-type representations for same-different comparisons, because if one wants to stick to such probabilistic representations one has to look for distributions with singularities; but on the other hand, the latter does not seem to be a natural constraint in psychophysics where on the contrar…
reviewed by: Salvatore Modica
Mathematics Subject Classification ID: 91E30
Mathematics Subject Classification ID: 62C05
Mathematics Subject Classification ID: 62P15
zbMATH DE Number: 1956183
MaRDI profile type: Publication
cites work: Differentiation of real functions
cites work: Conditionally selective dependence of random variables on external factors
cites work: Unconditionally selective dependence of random variables on external factors.
cites work: Multidimensional Fechnerian scaling: Regular variation version
cites work: Multidimensional Fechnerian scaling: probability-distance hypothesis.
cites work: Multidimensional Fechnerian scaling: Perceptual separability.
cites work: Multidimensional Fechnerian scaling: Pairwise comparisons, regular minimality, and nonconstant self-similarity.
cites work: Selective influence through conditional independence
cites work: Thurstonian-type representations for ``same-different'' discriminations: probabilistic decisions and interdependent images.
cites work: Multidimensional Fechnerian scaling: basics
cites work: A multidimensional stochastic theory of similarity
cites work: Q5509729
cites work: Q4247696
cites work: Q5336864
cites work: Random relations, random utilities, and random functions
cites work: A characterization theorem for random utility variables
cites work: Q5768777
cites work: Some results on random utility models
cites work: Multidimensional scaling models for reaction times and same-different judgements
cites work: Separability and independence of dimensions within the same-different judgment task
full work available at URL: s0022-2496(02)00027-5
OpenAlex ID: W4247702349
description: scientific article; zbMATH DE number 1956183